2006 Minnesota Statutes

144E.11 AMBULANCE SERVICE APPLICATION PROCEDURE.
    Subdivision 1. Written application. Each prospective licensee and each present licensee
wishing to offer a new type or types of ambulance service or to expand a primary service area
shall make written application for a license to the board on a form provided by the board.
    Subd. 2. Application notice. The board shall promptly send notice of the completed
application to each county board, community health board, governing body of a regional
emergency medical services system designated under section 144E.50, ambulance service, and
municipality in the area in which ambulance service would be provided by the applicant. The
board shall publish the notice, at the applicant's expense, in the State Register and in a newspaper
in the municipality in which the base of operation is or will be located, or if no newspaper
is published in the municipality or if the service is or would be provided in more than one
municipality, in a newspaper published at the county seat of the county or counties in which the
service would be provided.
    Subd. 3. Comments. Each municipality, county, community health board, governing body
of a regional emergency medical services system, ambulance service, and other person wishing
to make recommendations concerning the disposition of the application shall make written
recommendations or comments opposing the application to the board within 30 days of the
publication of notice of the application in the State Register.
    Subd. 4. Contested case exemption; procedure. (a) If no more than five written comments
opposing the application have been received by the board under subdivision 3, and the board has
determined, after considering the factors listed under subdivision 6, that the proposed service or
expansion of primary service area is needed, the applicant shall be exempt from the contested
case hearing process under subdivision 5.
(b) An applicant exempted from a contested case hearing under this subdivision shall furnish
additional information, as requested by the board, to support its application. The board shall
approve the application and grant a license to the applicant within 30 days after final submission
of requested information to the board, and upon a determination by the board that the applicant
is in compliance with the rules adopted by the board and with the inspection requirements
of section 144E.18.
(c) If an applicant does not comply with the inspection requirements under section 144E.18
within one year of the board's approval of its application, the license shall be denied. The one-year
time limit applies to any licensing decision made by the board or to any prior licensing decision
made by the commissioner of health or an administrative law judge.
(d) If, after considering the factors under subdivision 6, the board determines that the
proposed service or expansion of primary service area is not needed, the case shall be treated
as a contested case under subdivision 5, paragraphs (c) to (g).
    Subd. 5. Contested case; procedure. (a) If more than five written comments opposing the
application are received by the board as specified under subdivision 3, the board shall give the
applicant the option of immediately proceeding to a contested case hearing or trying to resolve the
objections within 30 days.
(b) If, after considering the factors under subdivision 6, the board determines that the
proposed service or expansion of primary service area is not needed, the board shall give the
applicant the option of immediately proceeding to a contested case hearing or using up to 30 days
to satisfy the board that the proposed service or expansion of primary service area is needed.
(c) The board shall request that the chief administrative law judge appoint an administrative
law judge to hold a public hearing in the municipality in which the applicant's base of operation
is or will be located:
(1) if more than five opposing comments remain after 30 days;
(2) if, after considering the factors under subdivision 6, the board determines that the
proposed service or expansion of primary service area is not needed after 30 days; or
(3) at the applicant's initial request.
(d) If the applicant's base of operation is located outside of Minnesota, the hearing shall be
held at a location within the area in which service would be provided in Minnesota. The public
hearing shall be conducted as a contested case hearing under chapter 14. The board shall pay the
expenses for the hearing location and the administrative law judge.
(e) The board shall provide notice of the public hearing, at the applicant's expense, in the
State Register and in the newspaper or newspapers in which the notice was published under
subdivision 2 for two successive weeks at least ten days before the date of the hearing.
(f) The administrative law judge shall:
(1) hold a public hearing as specified in paragraphs (c) and (d);
(2) allow any interested person the opportunity to be heard, to be represented by counsel, and
to present oral and written evidence at the public hearing; and
(3) provide a transcript of the hearing at the expense of any individual requesting it.
(g) The administrative law judge shall review and comment upon the application and make
written recommendations as to its disposition to the board within 90 days of publication of notice
of the hearing in the State Register. In making the recommendations, the administrative law judge
shall consider and make written comments as to whether the proposed service or expansion in
primary service area is needed, based on consideration of the factors specified in subdivision 6.
    Subd. 6. Review criteria. When reviewing an application for licensure, the board and
administrative law judge shall consider the following factors:
(1) the recommendations or comments of the governing bodies of the counties,
municipalities, community health boards as defined under section 145A.09, subdivision 2, and
regional emergency medical services system designated under section 144E.50 in which the
service would be provided;
(2) the deleterious effects on the public health from duplication, if any, of ambulance services
that would result from granting the license;
(3) the estimated effect of the proposed service or expansion in primary service area on
the public health; and
(4) whether any benefit accruing to the public health would outweigh the costs associated
with the proposed service or expansion in primary service area. The administrative law judge shall
recommend that the board either grant or deny a license or recommend that a modified license be
granted. The reasons for the recommendation shall be set forth in detail. The administrative law
judge shall make the recommendations and reasons available to any individual requesting them.
    Subd. 7. Licensing decision. After receiving the administrative law judge's report, the board
shall approve or deny the application and grant the license within 60 days if the application is
approved, and upon determination by the board, that the applicant is in compliance with the rules
adopted by the board and with the inspection requirements of section 144E.18. In approving
or denying an application, the board shall consider the administrative law judge's report, the
evidence contained in the application, and any hearing record and other applicable evidence. The
board's decision shall be based on a consideration of the factors contained in subdivision 6. If the
board determines to grant the applicant a license, the applicant must comply with the inspection
requirements under 144E.18 within one year of the board's approval of the application or the
license will be denied. This one-year time limit applies to any licensing decision by the board or to
any prior licensing decision made by the commissioner of health or an administrative law judge.
    Subd. 8. Final decision. The board's decision made under subdivision 7 shall be the final
administrative decision. Any person aggrieved by the board's decision or action shall be entitled
to judicial review in the manner provided in sections 14.63 to 14.69.
    Subd. 9. Renewal requirements. An ambulance service license expires two years from the
date of licensure. An ambulance service must apply to the board for license renewal at least one
month prior to the expiration date of the license and must submit:
(1) an application prescribed by the board specifying any changes from the information
provided for prior licensure and any other information requested by the board to clarify
incomplete or ambiguous information presented in the application; and
(2) the appropriate fee as required under section 144E.29.
History: 1997 c 199 s 6; 1999 c 245 art 9 s 26; 1Sp2003 c 14 art 8 s 1