65B.53 INDEMNITY; ARBITRATION BETWEEN OBLIGORS; SUBROGATION.
Subdivision 1. Indemnity from obligor of commercial vehicle.
A reparation obligor paying
or obligated to pay basic or optional economic loss benefits is entitled to indemnity subject
to the limits of the applicable residual liability coverage from a reparation obligor providing
residual liability coverage on a commercial vehicle of more than 5,500 pounds curb weight if
negligence in the operation, maintenance or use of the commercial vehicle was the direct and
proximate cause of the injury for which the basic economic loss benefits were paid or payable to
the extent that the insured would have been liable for damages but for the deduction provisions of
65B.51, subdivision 1
For purposes of this subdivision, a "commercial vehicle of more than 5,500 pounds curb
weight" does not include a vehicle listed in section
65B.47, subdivision 1a
Subd. 2. Obligor subrogated to economic loss claim.
A reparation obligor paying or
obligated to pay basic or optional economic loss benefits is subrogated to the claim for the
recovery of damages for economic loss that the person to whom the basic or optional economic
loss benefits were paid or payable has against another person whose negligence in another state
was the direct and proximate cause of the injury for which the basic economic loss benefits were
paid or payable. This right of subrogation exists only to the extent that basic economic loss
benefits are paid or payable and only to the extent that recovery on the claim absent subrogation
would produce a duplication of benefits or reimbursement of the same loss.
Subd. 3. Obligor subrogated to certain tort, liability, or negligence claim.
obligor paying or obligated to pay basic economic loss benefits is subrogated to a claim based
on an intentional tort, strict or statutory liability, or negligence other than negligence in the
maintenance, use, or operation of a motor vehicle. This right of subrogation exists only to the
extent that basic economic loss benefits are paid or payable and only to the extent that recovery
on the claim absent subrogation would produce a duplication of benefits or reimbursement of
the same loss.
Subd. 4. Indemnity enforced through arbitration.
The right of indemnity provided in
subdivision 1 shall be enforceable only through mandatory good-faith and binding arbitration
procedures established by rule of the commissioner of commerce. These procedures shall utilize
determinations of comparative negligence. No evidence nor the decision in such an arbitration
proceeding shall be admissible in any action by any party.
Subd. 5. Collision coverage subrogation.
Except as provided in this section nothing in
shall limit or abridge the subrogation rights of a reparation obligor
providing collision coverage to a policyholder.
Subd. 6. Other restrictions.
No reparation obligor shall include in its contract any provision
which would require a person to commence a negligence action as a condition precedent to the
payment of basic economic loss benefits or which permits the reparation obligor to determine
whether such an action will be commenced. No reparation obligor shall contract for a right of
reimbursement or subrogation greater than or in addition to those permitted by this chapter.
Subd. 7. Arbitration proceedings and benefit payments.
Arbitration proceedings need not
await final payment of benefits, and the award, if any, shall include provision for reimbursement
of subsequent benefits, but no question of fact decided by a prior award shall be reconsidered
in any such subsequent arbitration hearing.
Subd. 8. Enforceability of subrogation right.
Notwithstanding any law to the contrary,
in any action brought for the recovery of damages allegedly caused by the negligent operation,
ownership, maintenance or use of a motor vehicle or motorcycle where the right of subrogation
is claimed or may be claimed under this section, or in any counterclaim to such an action, the
right of an insurer to be subrogated to all or a portion of the claim of an insured, whether the right
to subrogation arises from contract, statute or any other source, shall be enforceable against the
insured only if the insurer, upon demand by the insured, agrees to pay a share of the attorney fees
and costs incurred to prosecute the claim, in such proportion as the insurer's subrogated interest in
the claim bears to any eventual recovery on the claim.
History: 1974 c 408 s 13; 1976 c 79 s 1; 1977 c 188 s 1,2; 1977 c 266 s 5; 1979 c 190 s 2;
1983 c 289 s 114 subd 1; 1984 c 655 art 1 s 92; 1993 c 362 s 1