2006 Minnesota Statutes

221.151 PERMIT ASSIGNABLE OR TRANSFERABLE.
    Subdivision 1. Petition. Permits, except livestock permits, issued under section 221.121 may
be assigned or transferred but only upon the order of the commissioner approving the transfer or
assignment after notice and hearing.
The proposed seller and buyer or lessor and lessee of a permit, except for livestock carrier
permits, shall file a joint notarized petition with the commissioner setting forth the name and
address of the parties, the identifying number of the permit, and the description of the authority
which the parties seek to sell or lease, a short statement of the reasons for the proposed sale
or lease, a statement of outstanding claims of creditors which are directly attributable to the
operation to be conducted under the permit, a copy of the contract of sale or lease, and a financial
statement with a balance sheet and an income statement, if existent, of the buyer or lessee. If it
appears to the commissioner, after notice to interested parties and a hearing, from the contents of
the petition, from the evidence produced at the hearing, and from the department's records, files,
and investigation that the approval of the sale or lease of the permit will not adversely affect the
rights of the users of the service and will not have an adverse effect upon other competing carriers,
the commissioner may make an order granting the sale or lease. Provided, however, that the
commissioner shall make no order granting the sale or lease of a permit to a person or corporation
or association which holds a certificate or permit other than local cartage carrier permit from the
commissioner under this chapter or to a common carrier by rail.
Provided further that the commissioner shall make no order approving the sale or lease
of a permit if the commissioner finds that the price paid for the sale or lease of a permit is
disproportionate to the reasonable value of the permit considering the assets and goodwill
involved. The commissioner shall approve the sale or lease of a permit only after a finding that
the transferee is fit and able to conduct the operations authorized under the permit and that the
vehicles the transferee proposes to use in conducting the operations meet the safety standards of
the commissioner. In determining the extent of the operating authority to be conducted by the
transferee under the sale or lease of the permit, the past operations of the transferor within the
two-year period immediately preceding the transfer must be considered. Only such operating
authority may be granted to the transferee as was actually exercised by the transferor under the
transferor's authority within the two-year period immediately preceding the transfer as evidenced
by bills of lading, company records, operation records, or other relevant evidence. For purposes
of determining the two-year period, the date of divesting of interest or control is the date of the
sale. The commissioner shall look to the substance of the transaction rather than the form. An
agreement for the transfer or sale of a permit must be reported and filed with the commissioner
within 30 days of the agreement.
If an authority to operate as a permit carrier is held by a corporation, a sale, assignment,
pledge, or other transfer of the stock interest in the corporation which will accomplish a substantial
or material change or transfer of the majority ownership of the corporation, as exercised through
its stockholders, must be reported in the manner prescribed in the rules of the commissioner
within 30 days after the sale, assignment, pledge, or other transfer of stock. The commissioner
shall then make a finding whether or not the stock transfer does, in fact, constitute a sale, lease,
or other transfer of the permit of the corporation to a new party or parties and, if they so find,
then the continuance of the permit issued to the corporation may only be upon the corporation's
complying with the standards and procedures otherwise imposed by this section.
    Subd. 2.MS 1974 [Repealed, 1973 c 710 s 2; 1974 c 406 s 93]
    Subd. 2. Ex parte transfer. (a) The commissioner shall allow a bona fide transfer of a permit,
except a livestock carrier permit, ex parte without hearing if the transferee of the permit is in fact
a member or members of the transferor's immediate family. For the purpose of this subdivision
immediate family consists only of the lawful spouse, adult child or children, brother, or sister of
the transferor. Provided further that the immediate family as defined in this subdivision does not
include a person under legal disability or a member of the family regardless of relationship who
holds any other permit or certificate under this chapter either as an individual or in partnership or
as owner of an interest in a corporation holding a permit or a certificate under this chapter.
(b) Provided further that the transfer under this subdivision must include:
(1) transfer to a corporation the stock of which is wholly owned by the transferor or
immediate family members;
(2) transfer to a partnership or partner consisting solely of the immediate family as defined in
this subdivision.
(c) Provided further that the transfer of a permit under this subdivision must comply with the
standards set forth in this section based upon the contents of the petition of petitioners, pertinent
information available to the commissioner, and their records and files. No determination of the
extent of the operating authority previously exercised is required.
(d) If it appears to the commissioner that the petition and exhibits do not reasonably
comply with the standards set forth in this section, then after notice to interested parties and the
petitioners, the commissioner shall assign the matter for hearing to determine compliance with
this section. A user of the service, competing carrier, or interested party shall have the right to
file a protest on the transfer as provided in this subdivision by filing a sworn statement with the
commissioner within six months from the date of the transfer, whereupon the commissioner shall
assign the matter for hearing and the continuance of the permit may only be upon the transferee's
compliance with the standards and procedures otherwise imposed by this section.
    Subd. 3. Transfer of certain authority. Operating authority described in section 221.121,
subdivision 6f , paragraph (c), that has not been added to the motor carrier's permit under section
221.121, subdivision 6f, paragraph (d), may not be transferred to any person except a member of
the transferor's immediate family as defined in subdivision 2.
History: Ex1957 c 17 s 15; 1965 c 523 s 4; 1971 c 25 s 67; 1973 c 710 s 1; 1975 c 313 s
11,12; 1976 c 166 s 83; 1980 c 534 s 69; 1983 c 371 s 30; 1986 c 444; 1988 c 544 s 16; 1992 c
600 s 30; 2001 c 213 s 30