1.1 	A bill for an act
1.2 	relating to health; requiring hospitals to provide registered nurse staffing at levels 
1.3 	consistent with nationally accepted standards; requiring reporting of staffing levels; 
1.4 	prohibiting retaliation; imposing civil penalties; appropriating money;amending 
1.5 	Minnesota Statutes 2018, sections 144.7055; 148.264, subdivision 1; proposing 
1.6 	coding for new law in Minnesota Statutes, chapter 144.
1.7 	BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA:

1.8 	Section 1. [144.591] QUALITY PATIENT CARE ACT.
1.9 		Subdivision 1.Title. Sections 144.591 to 144.595 may be cited as the "Quality Patient 
1.10 	Care Act."
1.11 		Subd. 2.Definitions. (a) For purposes of sections 144.591 to 144.595, the following 
1.12 	terms have the meanings given.
1.13 	(b) "Assignment" means the provision of care to a patient for whom a direct-care 
1.14 	registered nurse has responsibility within the nurse's scope of practice.
1.15 	(c) "Charge nurse" means a nurse who:
1.16 	(1) oversees and supports a nursing staff for each shift;
1.17 	(2) serves as a unit resource and carries out duties that include assigning patients to 
1.18 	nurses in the oncoming shift, coordinating patient flow, relieving staff for breaks, and 
1.19 	operating as a safety valve in addressing emergency patient care issues and fluctuations in 
1.20 	patient acuity and nursing intensity on the unit; and
1.21 	(3) has received special orientation and training to serve as a charge nurse for a unit or 
1.22 	department in a hospital.
2.1 	(d) "Commissioner" means the commissioner of health.
2.2 	(e) "Direct-care registered nurse" means a registered nurse, as defined in section 148.171, 
2.3 	subdivision 20, who is nonsupervisory and nonmanagerial and who directly provides nursing 
2.4 	care to patients more than 60 percent of the time.
2.5 	(f) "Health care emergency" means a situation that creates an actual or imminent serious 
2.6 	threat to the health and safety of persons and that may require hospitals and other health 
2.7 	care facilities to provide an exceptional level of emergency services or other health care 
2.8 	services. A health care emergency may include a natural or man-made disaster or an illness 
2.9 	or health condition caused by bioterrorism or an infectious agent that causes a high probability 
2.10 	of a large number of deaths, serious or long-term disabilities, or substantial future harm.
2.11 	(g) "Nursing intensity" means a patient-specific, not diagnosis-specific, measurement 
2.12 	of nursing care resources expended during a patient's hospitalization. A measurement of 
2.13 	nursing intensity includes the complexity of care required for a patient and the knowledge 
2.14 	and skill needed by a nurse for the surveillance of patients in order to make continuous, 
2.15 	appropriate clinical decisions in the care of patients.
2.16 	(h) "Patient acuity" means the measure of a patient's severity of illness or medical 
2.17 	condition, including but not limited to the stability of physiological and psychological 
2.18 	parameters and the dependency needs of the patient and the patient's family. Higher patient 
2.19 	acuity requires more intensive nursing time and advanced nursing skills for continuous 
2.20 	surveillance.
2.21 	(i) "Skill mix" means the composition of nursing staff by licensure and education, 
2.22 	including but not limited to registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, and unlicensed 
2.23 	personnel.
2.24 	(j) "Surveillance" means the continuous process of observing patients for early detection 
2.25 	and intervention in an effort to prevent negative patient outcomes.
2.26 	(k) "Unit" means an area or location of a hospital where patients receive care based on 
2.27 	similar patient acuity and nursing intensity.
2.28 		Subd. 3.Compliance. A hospital licensed under sections 144.50 to 144.56 must comply 
2.29 	with this section and sections 144.592 to 144.594 as a condition of licensure.
2.30 		Subd. 4.Staffing. A hospital must, at all times, provide enough qualified registered 
2.31 	nursing personnel on duty to provide the standard of care that is necessary for the well-being 
2.32 	of the patients, consistent with nationally accepted, evidence-based standards established 
2.33 	by this section and professional nursing specialty organizations. A direct-care registered 
3.1 	nurse assigned to a patient shall directly provide the planning, supervision, implementation, 
3.2 	and evaluation of nursing care to the patient, and is responsible for the provision of care to 
3.3 	a particular patient within the nurse's scope of practice.
3.4 		Subd. 5.Staffing plans. A hospital must adopt and implement a staffing plan that 
3.5 	specifies the maximum number of patients that may be assigned to a direct-care registered 
3.6 	nurse for each unit of the hospital in order to ensure adequate staffing levels for patient 
3.7 	safety. Staffing plans adopted and implemented under this subdivision must establish staffing 
3.8 	levels that include the flexibility to increase the number of nurses required for a unit when 
3.9 	necessary for patient safety. Staffing plans must be developed in agreement with direct-care 
3.10 	registered nurses and must comply with the requirements in subdivision 6.
3.11 		Subd. 6.Assignment limits for direct care registered nurses. (a) A staffing plan 
3.12 	developed under subdivision 5 may not permit direct-care registered nurses to be assigned 
3.13 	more patients than the following for any shift:
3.14 	(1) one registered nurse to one patient in operating rooms, in trauma units, for female 
3.15 	patients in the second and third stages of labor, and for unstable patients requiring transfer 
3.16 	to another unit;
3.17 	(2) one registered nurse to two patients in postanesthesia care units and critical care 
3.18 	units, and for female patients in the first stage of labor;
3.19 	(3) one registered nurse to three patients in intermediate care newborn nurseries, telemetry 
3.20 	units, and emergency departments;
3.21 	(4) one registered nurse to four patients in medical and surgical units, in pediatric units, 
3.22 	for noncritical antepartum patients, and for any other patient care units for which specific 
3.23 	assignment limits are not established in this paragraph;
3.24 	(5) one registered nurse to five patients for rehabilitation care units and acute psychiatric 
3.25 	mental health or chemical dependency units; and
3.26 	(6) one registered nurse to six female patients, or three couplets, in uncomplicated 
3.27 	postpartum or routine well-baby units.
3.28 	(b) Nothing in this subdivision requires a hospital with lower patient assignment limits 
3.29 	than those established in paragraph (a) to increase its assignment limits.
3.30 	(c) Nothing in this subdivision limits the rights of organized nurses to bargain on the 
3.31 	issue of assignment limits.
4.1 		Subd. 7.Schedule for compliance. Hospitals must comply with the assignment limits 
4.2 	established in subdivision 6 no later than August 1, 2022, except that hospitals in a rural 
4.3 	area, as defined in United States Code, title 42, section 1395ww(d)(2)(D), must comply no 
4.4 	later than August 1, 2024. The commissioner of health shall establish a schedule by which 
4.5 	hospitals must comply with assignment limits.
4.6 		Subd. 8.Application of assignment limits to hospital nursing practice standards. A 
4.7 	patient assignment may be included in the calculation of direct-care registered 
4.8 	nurse-to-patient assignment limits established in subdivision 6 only if care is provided by 
4.9 	a direct-care registered nurse and the provision of care to the particular patient is within 
4.10 	that direct-care registered nurse's validated competence.
4.11 		Subd. 9.Nursing administrators and supervisors. A hospital shall not include a nursing 
4.12 	administrator or supervisor in the calculation of direct-care registered nurse-to-patient 
4.13 	assignment limits established in subdivision 6. For purposes of this subdivision, "nursing 
4.14 	administrator or supervisor" includes a nurse administrator, nurse supervisor, nurse manager, 
4.15 	charge nurse, and case manager.
4.16 		Subd. 10.Application of assignment limits. The assignment limits established in 
4.17 	subdivision 6 represent the maximum number of patients to which a direct-care registered 
4.18 	nurse may be assigned at all points during a shift. A hospital is prohibited from averaging 
4.19 	the number of patients and the total number of direct-care registered nurses assigned to 
4.20 	patients in a unit during any one shift or over any period of time, in order to meet the 
4.21 	assignment limits established in subdivision 6.
4.22 		Subd. 11.Assignments, assignment adjustments, and adding additional registered 
4.23 	nurses. (a) A hospital must assign nursing personnel to the patient population consistent 
4.24 	with the hospital's staffing plan and the assignment limits established in subdivision 6. For 
4.25 	each patient population, a direct-care registered nurse shall evaluate the following factors 
4.26 	to assess and determine adequacy of staffing levels to meet patient care needs:
4.27 	(1) composition of skill mix and roles available;
4.28 	(2) patient acuity;
4.29 	(3) experience level of registered nurse staff;
4.30 	(4) unit activity level, such as admissions, discharges, and transfers;
4.31 	(5) variable staffing grids;
4.32 	(6) availability of a registered nurse to accept an assignment; and
5.1 	(7) nursing intensity.
5.2 	(b) A hospital shall not:
5.3 	(1) assign a direct-care registered nurse to provide patient care to a patient population 
5.4 	unless the direct-care registered nurse is able to demonstrate current competence in providing 
5.5 	care to the patient population and has received orientation sufficient to provide competent 
5.6 	care to the patient population;
5.7 	(2) assign nursing personnel from a supplemental nursing services agency to provide 
5.8 	patient care to a patient population until the agency nurse is able to demonstrate validated 
5.9 	competence in providing care to that patient population and has received orientation sufficient 
5.10 	to provide competent care to the patient population; or
5.11 	(3) assign unlicensed personnel to:
5.12 	(i) perform direct-care registered nurse functions in lieu of care delivered by a direct-care 
5.13 	registered nurse;
5.14 	(ii) perform tasks that require the assessment, judgment, or skill of a direct-care registered 
5.15 	nurse; or
5.16 	(iii) perform functions of a direct-care registered nurse under the supervision of a 
5.17 	direct-care registered nurse.
5.18 	(c) If any direct-care registered nurse determines that a unit's staffing levels are inadequate 
5.19 	and so notifies the unit's charge nurse and a manager or administrative supervisor, the 
5.20 	manager or administrative supervisor shall consider the following:
5.21 	(1) current patient care assignments for potential redistribution;
5.22 	(2) the ability to facilitate discharges, transfers, and admissions;
5.23 	(3) the availability of additional staffing resources; and
5.24 	(4) the hospital-wide census and staffing.
5.25 	(d) If the staffing inadequacies cannot be resolved and resources cannot be reallocated 
5.26 	by the manager or administrative supervisor after considering the factors in paragraph (c), 
5.27 	the hospital shall call in extra staff to ensure adequate staffing to meet safe patient standards.
5.28 	(e) Until extra staff arrive and begin to receive patient assignments:
5.29 	(1) the hospital must suspend nonemergency admissions and elective surgeries that 
5.30 	routinely lead to in-patient hospitalization; and
6.1 	(2) the charge nurse for the unit with inadequate staffing levels is authorized to close 
6.2 	the unit to new patient admissions and in-hospital transfers.
6.3 		Subd. 12.Prohibited actions. A hospital must not take any of the following actions as 
6.4 	a means to meet staffing standards:
6.5 	(1) use mandatory overtime;
6.6 	(2) assign or transfer a direct-care registered nurse to a patient care unit until after the 
6.7 	nurse has been adequately trained and oriented to work on the unit;
6.8 	(3) assign a direct-care registered nurse to a patient care unit to relieve another direct-care 
6.9 	registered nurse during breaks, meals, or other routine and expected absences from a unit, 
6.10 	until after the nurse being assigned demonstrates current competence in providing care on 
6.11 	a particular unit and has received orientation to that hospital's unit sufficient to provide 
6.12 	competent care to patients in that unit; or
6.13 	(4) impose layoffs of licensed practical nurses, licensed psychiatric technicians, certified 
6.14 	nursing assistants, or other ancillary staff to meet the assignment limits established in 
6.15 	subdivision 6.
6.16 		Subd. 13.Exemption; emergency situations. The assignment limits established in 
6.17 	subdivision 6 do not apply during a health care emergency if a hospital needs to provide an 
6.18 	exceptional level of emergency services or other health care services. If a health care 
6.19 	emergency causes a change in the number of patients on a unit, a hospital must make prompt 
6.20 	and diligent efforts to maintain staffing levels consistent with the assignment limits 
6.21 	established in subdivision 6. The commissioner shall provide guidance to hospitals describing 
6.22 	situations that constitute a health care emergency for purposes of this subdivision.
6.23 		Subd. 14.Charge nurse; inclusion in staffing grid. In order to facilitate optimal patient 
6.24 	care, a charge nurse shall not be included in the unit's staffing grid which is regularly 
6.25 	reviewed and determines the unit's staffing budget. This subdivision does not limit the ability 
6.26 	of a charge nurse to take a patient assignment in the event of an emergency, when taking a 
6.27 	patient assignment, in the charge nurse's professional opinion, will not jeopardize overall 
6.28 	patient care for all patients on the unit at that time.

6.29 	Sec. 2. [144.592] PATIENT CARE; USE OF TECHNOLOGY.
6.30 		Subdivision 1.Patient-acuity adjustable units prohibited. Patients shall be cared for 
6.31 	only on units or patient care areas where the level of intensity, type of care, and direct-care 
6.32 	registered nurse-to-patient assignment limits meet the individual requirements and needs 
6.33 	of each patient.
7.1 		Subd. 2.Use of technology. (a) A hospital shall not employ video monitors or any form 
7.2 	of electronic visualization of a patient as a substitute for the direct observation required for 
7.3 	patient assessment by a direct-care registered nurse or required for patient protection. Video 
7.4 	monitors or any form of electronic visualization of a patient shall not be included in the 
7.5 	calculation of assignment limits established in section 144.591, subdivision 6.
7.6 	(b) A hospital shall not employ technology that limits a direct-care registered nurse from 
7.7 	performing functions that are part of the nursing process, including full exercise of 
7.8 	independent professional judgment in assessment, planning, implementation, and evaluation 
7.9 	of care.

7.10 	Sec. 3. [144.593] SAFE PATIENT ASSIGNMENT COMMITTEE.
7.11 		Subdivision 1.Committee required. By October 1, 2020, a hospital must establish a 
7.12 	Safe Patient Assignment Committee either by creating a new committee or assigning the 
7.13 	functions of a staffing for patient safety committee to an existing committee.
7.14 		Subd. 2.Membership; compensation. At least 60 percent of the committee's membership 
7.15 	must be nonsupervisory and nonmanagerial registered nurses who provide direct patient 
7.16 	care, as defined in section 144.591, subdivision 2, paragraph (e). The committee must include 
7.17 	members appointed by a collective bargaining unit to proportionately represent its nurses. 
7.18 	Hospitals must compensate registered nurses who are employed by the hospital and serve 
7.19 	on the Safe Patient Assignment Committee for time spent on committee business.
7.20 		Subd. 3.Duties. A Safe Patient Assignment Committee shall:
7.21 	(1) complete a staffing for patient safety assessment by March 31, 2021, and annually 
7.22 	thereafter that identifies the following:
7.23 	(i) problems of insufficient staffing including but not limited to an inappropriate number 
7.24 	of registered nurses scheduled in a unit, inappropriately experienced registered nurses 
7.25 	scheduled for a particular unit, inability for nurse supervisors to adjust for increased acuity 
7.26 	or activity in a unit, and chronically unfilled positions within the hospital;
7.27 	(ii) units that pose the highest risk to patient safety due to inadequate staffing; and
7.28 	(iii) solutions for problems identified under items (i) and (ii);
7.29 	(2) implement and evaluate assignment limits established in section 144.591, subdivision 
7.30 	6;
7.31 	(3) convert assignment limits established in section 144.591, subdivision 6, into registered 
7.32 	nurse hours of care per patient;
8.1 	(4) recommend a mechanism for tracking and analyzing staffing trends within the 
8.2 	hospital;
8.3 	(5) develop a procedure for making shift-to-shift adjustments in staffing levels consistent 
8.4 	with section 144.591, subdivision 11, when such adjustments are required by patient acuity 
8.5 	and nursing intensity; and
8.6 	(6) identify any incidents when the hospital has failed to meet the assignment limits 
8.7 	established in section 144.591, subdivision 6, and recommend a remedy.

8.8 	Sec. 4. [144.594] RETALIATION PROHIBITED.
8.9 	A hospital shall not retaliate against or discipline a direct-care registered nurse, either 
8.10 	formally or informally, for:
8.11 	(1) refusing to accept an assignment if, in good faith and in the nurse's professional 
8.12 	judgment, the nurse determined that the assignment is unsafe for patients due to patient 
8.13 	acuity and nursing intensity; or
8.14 	(2) reporting a concern regarding safe staffing levels.

8.15 	Sec. 5. [144.595] ENFORCEMENT.
8.16 	(a) The commissioner shall impose a civil penalty of not less than $25,000 for each 
8.17 	incident of a hospital failing to comply with sections 144.591 to 144.594, including failure 
8.18 	to staff patient care units to required levels.
8.19 	(b) At a minimum, the commissioner must publicly report on the department website 
8.20 	all incidents of noncompliance with sections 144.591 to 144.595 on a quarterly basis, 
8.21 	beginning September 1, 2019.

8.22 	Sec. 6. Minnesota Statutes 2018, section 144.7055, is amended to read:
8.23 	144.7055 STAFFING PLAN REPORTS.
8.24 		Subdivision 1.Definitions. (a) For the purposes of this section, the following terms have 
8.25 	the meanings given.
8.26 	(b) "Core staffing plan" means the projected number of full-time equivalent 
8.27 	nonmanagerial care staff that will be assigned in a 24-hour period to an inpatient care unit.
8.28 	(c) "Nonmanagerial care staff" means registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, and 
8.29 	other health care workers, which may include but is not limited to nursing assistants, nursing 
8.30 	aides, patient care technicians, and patient care assistants, who perform nonmanagerial 
9.1 	direct patient care functions for more than 50 percent of their scheduled hours on a given 
9.2 	patient care unit.
9.3 	(d) "Inpatient care unit" means a designated inpatient area for assigning patients and 
9.4 	staff for which a distinct staffing plan exists and that operates 24 hours per day, seven days 
9.5 	per week in a hospital setting. Inpatient care unit does not include any hospital-based clinic, 
9.6 	long-term care facility, or outpatient hospital department.
9.7 	(e) "Staffing hours per patient day" means the number of full-time equivalent 
9.8 	nonmanagerial care staff who will ordinarily be assigned to provide direct patient care 
9.9 	divided by the expected average number of patients upon which such assignments are based.
9.10 	(f) "Patient acuity tool" means a system for measuring an individual patient's need for 
9.11 	nursing care. This includes utilizing a professional registered nursing assessment of patient 
9.12 	condition to assess staffing need.
9.13 	(f) "Direct-care registered nurse" means a registered nurse, as defined in section 148.171, 
9.14 	subdivision 20, who is nonsupervisory and nonmanagerial and is directly providing nursing 
9.15 	care to patients more than 60 percent of the time.
9.16 		Subd. 2.Hospital staffing report. (a) The chief nursing executive or nursing designee 
9.17 	of every reporting hospital in Minnesota under section 144.50will shall develop a core 
9.18 	staffing plan for each patient care unit.
9.19 	(b) Core staffing plans shall specify the full-time equivalent for each patient care unit 
9.20 	for each 24-hour period. following:
9.21 	(1) the definition of the patient care unit;
9.22 	(2) the number of beds available in each patient care unit;
9.23 	(3) the average number of patients per day in each patient care unit; and
9.24 	(4) the full-time equivalent for each patient care unit broken down by:
9.25 	(i) shift, based on eight-hour shifts of 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., 3:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m., 
9.26 	and 11:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m.; and
9.27 	(ii) type of staff assigned, including but not limited to registered nurses, licensed practical 
9.28 	nurses, certified nursing assistants, and other additional care team members.
9.29 	(c) Prior to submitting the core staffing plan, as required in subdivision 3, hospitals shall 
9.30 	consult with and obtain consent from representatives of the hospital medical staff, managerial 
9.31 	and nonmanagerial care staff, and other relevant hospital personnel about nonmanagerial 
9.32 	care staff and all affected exclusive bargaining representatives of nonmanagerial care staff 
10.1 	regarding the core staffing plan and the expected average number of patients upon which 
10.2 	the staffing plan is based. Direct-care registered nurses must certify the report as accurate 
10.3 	and clearly presented by majority vote of direct-care registered nurses on staff at the hospital 
10.4 	or by the exclusive bargaining representative if represented by a collective bargaining unit.
10.5 		Subd. 3.Standard electronic reporting developed. (a) Hospitals must submit the core 
10.6 	staffing plans to the Minnesota Hospital Association by January 1, 2014 on a quarterly 
10.7 	basis. The Minnesota Hospital Association shall include each reporting hospital's most 
10.8 	recently submitted core staffing plan on the Minnesota Hospital Association's Minnesota 
10.9 	Hospital Quality Report website by April 1, 2014 within three months after submission. 
10.10 	Any substantial changes to the core staffing plan shall be updated within 30 days.
10.11 	(b) The Minnesota Hospital Association shall include on its website for each reporting 
10.12 	hospital on a quarterly basis the actual direct patient care hours per patient, per shift, based 
10.13 	on eight-hour shifts of 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., 3:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m., and 11:00 p.m. to 
10.14 	7:00 a.m., and per unit. Hospitals must submit the direct patient care report to the Minnesota 
10.15 	Hospital Association by July 1, 2014, and quarterly thereafter each quarter, and the Minnesota 
10.16 	Hospital Association must post the actual direct patient care staffing report on the hospital 
10.17 	quality reporting website within three months of receiving the reports.
10.18 		Subd. 4.Enforcement of reporting requirements. (a) The commissioner shall impose 
10.19 	a civil penalty of not less than $25,000 for each hospital that fails to comply with subdivisions 
10.20 	2 and 3, including failure to report by the deadline or failure to provide information according 
10.21 	to the requirements of this section. Each day of the violation shall constitute a separate 
10.22 	violation and the penalties prescribed shall be applicable to each separate violation unless 
10.23 	otherwise indicated.
10.24 	(b) At a minimum, the commissioner must publicly report on the department website 
10.25 	all incidents of noncompliance with subdivision 2 or 3.
10.26 		Subd. 5.Staffing grid; compliance; enforcement. (a) A hospital must submit its staffing 
10.27 	grid to the commissioner quarterly and, when scheduling staff for a patient care unit, must 
10.28 	schedule at least the number and skill mix of staff specified in the staffing grid for that unit.
10.29 	(b) The commissioner shall accept complaints from persons employed by a hospital 
10.30 	regarding situations in which a hospital scheduled fewer staff for a patient care unit than 
10.31 	the number of staff specified in the hospital's staffing grid, or a skill mix that differed 
10.32 	substantially from the skill mix specified in the hospital's staffing grid. The commissioner 
10.33 	shall impose a civil penalty of not less than $25,000 for:
10.34 	(1) a hospital that fails to submit its staffing grid according to paragraph (a); or
11.1 	(2) situations in which the commissioner determines that a hospital scheduled fewer 
11.2 	staff for a patient care unit than the number of staff specified in the staffing grid or scheduled 
11.3 	a skill mix of staff that differed substantially from the skill mix specified in the hospital's 
11.4 	staffing grid.

11.5 	Sec. 7. Minnesota Statutes 2018, section 148.264, subdivision 1, is amended to read:
11.6 		Subdivision 1.Reporting. (a) Any person, health care facility, business, or organization 
11.7 	is immune from civil liability or criminal prosecution for submitting in good faith a report 
11.8 	to the board under section 148.263 or for otherwise reporting in good faith to the board 
11.9 	violations or alleged violations of sections 148.171 to 148.285. All such reports are 
11.10 	investigative data as defined in chapter 13.
11.11 	(b) Any registered nurse or health care worker who experiences and subsequently reports 
11.12 	a level of staffing that in the registered nurse's or health care worker's professional judgment 
11.13 	could reasonably be expected to result in unsafe or ineffective patient care cannot be 
11.14 	disciplined under section 148.261, subdivision 1, clause (8). These reports may include a 
11.15 	report from a registered nurse or health care worker to the registered nurse's or health care 
11.16 	worker's supervisor at the supervisor's place of employment, the Board of Nursing, the 
11.17 	commissioner of health, or a professional nursing organization. Reports must be made within 
11.18 	ten calendar days after the incident in order to be covered under this paragraph.

11.19 	Sec. 8. APPROPRIATION.
 11.20 	$....... in fiscal year 2020 and $....... in fiscal year 2021 are appropriated from the general 
11.21 	fund to the commissioner of health for enforcement activities in Minnesota Statutes, section 
11.22 	144.7055, subdivision 5.